Offseason in review for the Atlanta Braves

The Braves made a couple early offseason strikes to bolster the pitching depth and install a former top prospect as their new left fielder. Their biggest move came right around the New Year with the acquisition and extension of a one-time ace whom they’re hoping will get back on track in 2024.

Major League signings

• RHP Reynaldo Lopez: Three years, $30M (including buyout of 2027 club option)
• 2B Luis Guillorme: One year, $1.1M (eligible for arbitration through 2025)
• LHP Angel Perdomo: One year split deal (under team control through 2028)
• RHP Jackson Stephens: One year split deal (under team control through 2027)
• RHP Penn Murfee: One year split deal (under team control through 2028)

Option decisions

• Team declined its end of $7M mutual option on LHP Brad Hand in favor of $500K buyout
• Exercised $20M option on RHP Charlie Morton
• Declined $5.75M option on RHP Kirby Yates in favor of $1.25M buyout
• Declined $6M option on RHP Collin McHugh in favor of $1M buyout
• Declined $9M option on LF Eddie Rosario

Trades and claims

• Claimed LHP Angel Perdomo off waivers from Pirates (later non-tendered and re-signed to MLB deal)
• Claimed RHP Penn Murfee off waivers from Mariners (later non-tendered and re-signed to MLB deal)
• Acquired LHP Aaron Bummer from White Sox for LHP Jared Shuster, 2B Nicky Lopez, RHP Michael Soroka, SS Braden Shewmake and minor-league RHP Riley Gowens
• Acquired RHP Jackson Kowar from Royals for RHP Kyle Wright
• Traded RHP Nick Anderson to Royals for cash
• Acquired LF Jarred Kelenic, LHP Marco Gonzales, 1B Evan White and $4.5M from Mariners for RHP Jackson Kowar and minor-league RHP Cole Phillips
• Traded LHP Marco Gonzales and $9.25M to Pirates for cash
• Acquired SS David Fletcher (later outrighted to Triple-A) and C Max Stassi from Angels for minor-league 1B Evan White and minor-league LHP Tyler Thomas
• Traded C Max Stassi and $6.26M to White Sox for a player to be named later or cash
• Acquired LHP Ray Kerr, DH Matt Carpenter (later released) and $1.5M from Padres for minor-league OF Drew Campbell
• Acquired LHP Chris Sale and $17M from Red Sox for 2B Vaughn Grissom
• Acquired LF J.P. Martínez from Rangers for minor-league RHP Tyler Owens

Notable minor-league signings

• Skye Bolt, Ben Bowden, Charlie Culberson, Tommy Doyle, Phillip Evans, Leury García, Ken Giles, Luis Liberato, Zach Logue, Alejo López, Jordan Luplow, Sebastian Rivero, Chadwick Tromp, Andrew Velazquez, Jake Walsh, Taylor Widener, Luke Williams

Extensions

• Signed RHP Pierce Johnson to two-year, $14.25M deal (including buyout of 2026 club option)
• Signed RHP Joe Jimenez to three-year, $26M deal
• Signed LHP Chris Sale to two-year, $38M deal (includes club option for 2026)

Notable losses

• Kolby Allard (non-tendered), Yonny Chirinos (non-tendered), Ben Heller, Sam Hilliard (lost on waivers), Grissom, McHugh (retired), Rosario, Shewmake, Shuster, Soroka, Michael Tonkin (non-tendered), Wright

While the first few weeks of the offseason were generally fairly quiet around the league, the Braves struck early. They began their work before the offseason technically began. Within two weeks of being bounced in the NL Division Series, Atlanta kept one of their free agents off the market.

The Braves inked Pierce Johnson to a two-year, $14.25M extension, keeping the deadline pickup in the high-leverage mix after a dominant second half. The bullpen investment continued in early November. Joe Jiménez inked a three-year, $26M pact (on a rare Atlanta extension that didn’t include a team option at the end) days before he would’ve been able to explore the open market.

President of baseball operations Alex Anthopoulos and his staff didn’t stop there. They orchestrated the first offseason trade of significance with the White Sox, sending five players to Chicago for lefty reliever Aaron Bummer. It’s a bet on Bummer’s velocity and strong strikeout and ground-ball rates despite his 6.79 ERA from a season ago. Atlanta subtracted back-of-the-roster depth in parting with rotation candidates Michael Soroka and Jared Shuster and infielders Nicky Lopez and Braden Shewmake. No one from that group projected to play a significant role early in the 2024 season, making that an easier call for the front office.

With that level of early investment in the bullpen, it came as a surprise when the Braves dipped into free agency for yet another power arm who has spent the past couple seasons as a reliever. Reynaldo Lopez inked a three-year, $30M pact. That price point isn’t too surprising in itself, but the subsequent revelation that the Braves will allow him to compete for a rotation spot was unexpected. Lopez struggled as a starting pitcher early in his career with the White Sox. He has been far better in relief over the last few seasons, yet it’s still fair to question whether he has the level of command necessary to be an effective starter.

Lopez is battling the likes of AJ Smith-Shawver, Bryce Elder, Huascar Ynoa and top prospect Hurston Waldrep for the final spot in the starting five. That’s a high-octane collection of depth arms behind one of the sport’s strongest front fours. Spencer Strider and Max Fried are back in their customary top two rotation spots. The Braves exercised a $20M option to keep Charlie Morton for his fourth season in Atlanta.

There was never a question they’d add one more established starter behind the Strider, Fried and Morton trio. The source of intrigue was which pitcher that would be. The Braves were tied to Georgia native Dylan Cease in trade rumors early in the winter but balked at the White Sox’s asking price. Ultimately, they turned to a pitcher few expected to be traded: Chris Sale.

Sale narrowly topped 100 innings over 20 starts for the Red Sox last season, his first time hitting the century mark since 2019. A pedestrian 4.30 ERA belied a much more impressive 29.4% strikeout rate and 13.2% swinging strike percentage. The stuff that had made Sale an ace earlier in his career seems mostly intact. Yet there’s risk in betting on a pitcher who turns 35 this month and has missed extended stretches over the past three seasons because of Tommy John surgery, a broken finger, a wrist fracture and last year’s bout of shoulder inflammation.

Between that injury history and a hefty $27.5M salary, it seemed unlikely the Red Sox would find a taker for Sale. Atlanta got around the latter concern by convincing Boston to eat $17M. With another $10M of the salary set to be deferred, Sale essentially cost the Braves nothing this year financially. Getting the Sox to pay down that large a portion of the salary required parting with one of Atlanta’s top young players.

While Vaughn Grissom has technically exhausted his prospect eligibility, he was essentially Atlanta’s best young position player who was not already a key piece of the Major League roster. The 23-year-old has hit .287/.339/.407 in scattered big league looks over the last two seasons. He’s coming off a .330/.419/.501 showing in Triple-A. Grissom could be an average or better MLB second baseman as soon as this year. His path to playing time on the Truist Park infield has long been blocked, so it seemed the Braves would cash him in for rotation help at some point.

Atlanta doubled down on the dice roll on Sale by reworking his contract. They signed him to a restructured two-year, $38M deal not long after the trade. That reduced the team’s luxury tax obligations in the short term and tacked on a club option for the 2026 season while guaranteeing the lanky southpaw a $22M salary for ’25 – a year that had previously been covered by a team option.

That completed the big work on the pitching staff. As has been the case for a few offseasons, the Braves entered the winter with a mostly settled group of hitters. Eight members of last year’s primary lineup are back. The one unsettled position was left field. Atlanta declined a $9M option on Eddie Rosario, leaving that as the sole lineup spot which they needed to address.

While the Braves loosely floated the possibility of moving Grissom to left field before his inclusion in the Sale trade, they took that off the table at the winter meetings. Atlanta leveraged financial space to take a change-of-scenery look at former top prospect Jarred Kelenic. The left-handed hitter was a disappointment in Seattle, where he hit .204/.283/.373 over parts of three seasons.

Kelenic is coming off a career-best offensive showing, as he turned in a decent .253/.327/.419 batting line over 416 plate appearances last year. It wasn’t an entirely positive season, though. He struck out at a borderline untenable 31.7% rate, continuing the issues making contact that have plagued him throughout his career. Kelenic also missed a couple months with a self-inflicted foot fracture sustained when he kicked a water cooler in frustration after a strikeout.

Controllable for five seasons and a year away from arbitration, Kelenic himself isn’t costing the Braves much for the upcoming campaign. They did take a good chunk of dead money off Seattle’s books. The Braves added $24.5M in salary on Marco Gonzales and Evan White. The actual return – reliever Jackson Kowar, acquired weeks earlier from the Royals for injured starter Kyle Wright, and mid-level pitching prospect Cole Phillips – wasn’t exorbitant. Kelenic will get an opportunity to play every day in left field, which isn’t surprising considering the amount of salary and luxury tax fees they took on to get him.

The Kelenic trade kicked off a series of additions in which the Braves ate underwater contracts to acquire depth pieces of interest. They offloaded Gonzales to the Pirates for nothing more than $2.75M in savings on his $12M contract. White went to the Angels in a bizarre move that saw Atlanta take on the deals of infielder David Fletcher and catcher Max Stassi. The Braves added an extra $6M to the books, ostensibly to add Fletcher in the glove-first utility role which Nicky Lopez had played down the stretch.

Atlanta ate all but the league minimum on Stassi and flipped him to the White Sox for nothing, while they ran Fletcher through outright waivers. The latter remains in the organization in a non-roster capacity and could still get to the majors this year, but the subsequent signing of Luis Guillorme to a $1.1MM free agent deal makes him a bit redundant. The Fletcher/White swap seemed unnecessary in the larger context of the offseason.

The Braves made one more trade of this ilk in mid-December. Atlanta absorbed $4M on Matt Carpenter’s salary to bring in hard-throwing reliever Ray Kerr from the Padres. The Braves released Carpenter (he subsequently signed a big league deal to return to the Cardinals), but Kerr is an intriguing lefty bullpen arm who can still be optioned to the minors. That’s a plus for a team that has seven relievers – Raisel Iglesias, A.J. Minter, Jimenez, Johnson, Tyler Matzek, Bummer and Jackson Stephens – who cannot be sent down without clearing waivers. All but Stephens are locks to be in the MLB bullpen if healthy.

It’s debatable whether the series of maneuvers at the back of the roster improves the Braves enough that it was worthwhile. It at least highlights the kind of flexibility afforded the front office by constructing a team with such a strong core. The Braves made a couple other small-scale changes.

They dealt veteran middle reliever Nick Anderson to the Royals, acquired fifth outfielder J.P. Martínez from the Rangers, and took minimal fliers on injury rehabbers Penn Murfee and Angel Perdomo as forward-looking bullpen moves. It amounts to a lot of tinkering in an offseason that’ll be defined by the Sale, Kelenic and (to lesser extents) Lopez and Bummer acquisitions.

Most of last year’s star-studded group is back. The catching tandem of Sean Murphy and Travis d’Arnaud remains in place. Ditto the starting infield of Matt Olson, Ozzie Albies, Orlando Arcia and Austin Riley. Defending NL MVP Ronald Acuña Jr. dodged a scare with his right knee and should be in the Opening Day outfield beside Michael Harris II and Kelenic. Marcell Ozuna is under contract for one more season at designated hitter.

Maintaining perfect continuity is impossible for any team. The Braves parted with Rosario, Wright, Soroka, Grissom and a couple ancillary veteran contributors in the bullpen. Longtime third base coach Ron Washington was finally poached for another managerial opportunity after years of speculation. He’s now in charge of the Angels dugout.

Despite that handful of departures, the Braves again head into the season with one of the strongest teams in the Majors. They’re still firmly in their championship window, though the more immediate concern will be snagging a seventh straight NL East title. Next offseason will bring more questions, particularly about the long-term state of the rotation with Fried trending towards free agency.